Raised in New York City, Lindsay attended the Riverdale Country School. She received her BFA in Drama from NYU Tisch School of the Arts, studying at the Stella Adler track. She moved to Chicago where she received a JEFF Citation Award for Supporting Actress in a Play in her first show outside of school. Lindsay recently graduated from the USC MFA Acting Program, where she received a scholarship. Lindsay is an accomplished skier and in her spare time frequents the mountains of Colorado.