Yael Hoffman is an Admission director of Ha Midrash L'Torah, the rabbinical school that Andy attends. She dismissively rebuffs Andy's initial request for admission; however, she provisionally admits him after reading a moving admission essay that she assigned him to write. Andy's sexual interest in Yael is transparent, and she toys and flirts with Andy. After a special cultural event at the school, she afrees to have sex with him. However, she turns the tables on Andy with a pegging encounter. She angrily dumps Andy when he quits rabbinical school. Andy refers to her as the one in both season four and season five. During a visit to Regrestic in the series' penultimate episode, Andy visits Yael, hoping to rekindle their romance. Yael, however, has no memory of ever meeting him.