Chad Warwick and his boyfriend Patrick had owned the haunted house in first season of American Horror Story. Chad had bought a rubber suit to try and win Patrick back when he found out he was cheating on him. On Halloween night, Chad had found the rubber suit on a man thinking it was Patrick, and was drowned by the rubber man. The rubber man fights off Patrick later; he drags the two bodies to the basement where they wake up and are both shot by Tate.