Eve Agnew (Kathleen Kole) is the the quiet, weird sister. During the movie, you see that Eve is an outcast and is thought to be weird by the other sisters. When the murders begin, Eve dissapears, raising suspicouns about her. The sisters find news-paper articles about a boy named Billy Lenz who killed his family 15 years earlier in the house in her bedroom. While trying to find the missing sisters, they discover Eve's decapitated head in her car.