Megan Helms (Jessica Harmon) is shown to be highly upset on Christmas Eve. It is later revealed this is becuase of a sex tape made of her and Kyle Autry (Oliver Hudson), who is now dating fellow sorority sister Kelli Presley (Katie Cassidy). While in her room, Megan hears music from the attic. She goes to investigate, thinking the sisters are just playing a joke on her to add to her already bad mood. She discovers Claire Crosby (Leela Savasta) dead body in the attic, but before having time to escape is attacked by the killer, having a bag pulled over her head. Megan struggles, but she is stabbed numerous times and has her eyes gouged out, killing her. Kelli later finds Megan and Kyle's sex tape on Megans laptop, causing the couple to break up.